mojira.dev
MC-46956

Monsters can be added to teams, but are not affected by teamrules

Upon delivery entities and players in a team, it seems that the entities (other than players) do not have a team because they are invisible when splashing invisibility potion even if seeFriendlyInvisibles true . They also focus player and hurt them (for monsters), although FriendlyFire is set to false. Players can also hit the monsters in their teams.

do with google translate

Linked issues

MC-50313 Team color does not apply to entities Resolved MC-50436 Friendly Fire false command does not affect entities Resolved MC-50717 Team-Scoreboard Bug with entities Resolved MC-51529 friendlyfire not affecting mobs Resolved MC-54097 Mobs added to a team while friendly fire is off can still be killed Resolved

Comments 14

Deleted account

Is this still a concern in the current Minecraft version 14w20b / Launcher version 1.3.11 or later? If so, please update the affected versions in order to best aid Mojang ensuring bugs are still valid in the latest releases/pre-releases.

It's currently not planned to apply the team options to any entities in a team.

Jonathon Alexander Zeyen

The snapshot for today isn't out yet so I don't know about that but it's still effecting the latest 14w27b.

it is out now

Still an issue in 14w34d

it would be very convenient if this were to work as expected

I would assume team dynamics would automatically be applied to anything that happens to be on a team, isn't that the basis of how object oriented programming works? it's fairly unfortunate and unexpected that this isn't the case.

4 more comments

Why certain things like the "scoreboard teamkill" works with mobs and others no, there are so many inconsistencies with things related with mobs and teams...

In what world is having this be 'intended' was a good idea? Mojang does this TOO often. Make it easier for map makers not harder. This should be opened back up. Ridiculous...

Requesting this to be reviewed.
Mobs hitting each other intentionally on teams are considered valid bugs and got fixed/triaged: MC-172304 (fixed), MC-95782 (tiaged), MC-225908 (triaged), MC-225907 (triaged), MC-150820 (triaged), MC-141401 (triaged).

When reviewed and reopened, this report should be reduced to just "mobs on teams with friendly fire set to false can still hit teammates accidentally"; the invisibility thing was fixed a long time ago, and most duplicates are about friendly fire.

There are elements of team rules which monsters respect. IT would be more useful or us to know what aspects of team rules are broken with mobs, instead of one general bug. Thanks.

Hence the second part of my comment. It's mainly projectile friendly fire, just like most duplicates are pointing out.
I'll go make new reports for this.

EDIT: MC-256019 and MC-256020.
EDIT2: MC-256096 and MC-256097 are not created too, after further testing.

FDB_hiroshima

(Unassigned)

Community Consensus

friendly, friendlyfire, mob, monster, team

Minecraft 14w05b, Minecraft 14w26c

Retrieved