mojira.dev
MCPE-17073

You can get drowned by Doors and Other Transparent Blocks (Still affects lava)

Device: Xiaomi Redmi 1S

In Survival Mode, I crafted an Oak Door & placed it. then when i pass by/stand right next to the door, I see the bubbles and when its depleted, I take damage like getting drowned underwater.

update by @unknown:
Now only affects

  • Lava (when submerged)

Steps to reproduce

  • Place a puddle of lava.

  • Give yourself fire resistance.

  • Switch to survival.

  • Swim under the lava.

  • Notice that breathing bubbles are show but your swimming in lava not water.

Related issues

MCPE-17077 Going through doors shows the underwater bubbles MCPE-17105 Drowning close to door MCPE-17108 Water bubbles appearing between opened doors MCPE-17129 Drowning while on door's block MCPE-17134 Oxygen Bar Visible When Entering Door MCPE-17152 every time I walk into a door sometimes die and sometimes appears as if I was drowning MCPE-17167 Oak door drowns you to death MCPE-17189 Air Bubbles show up when you are standing in a door! MCPE-17207 Standing In Front Of Signs, Door, Glass Pane, And Iron Bars Open The New Suffocation Bubbles In The Top Right Corner MCPE-17221 Doorways drown me MCPE-17225 The bubbles show in the top of screen when you stand in a doorway MCPE-17230 Drowning in doors MCPE-17313 Steve drowns MCPE-17324 Respiration/Oxygen bug (Water Bubbles bug) MCPE-17328 [Duplicates with MCPE-17073] Doors and signs makes us to die by suffocating when we're into them MCPE-17330 When I walk through a door it says I'm drowning, when meter depletes I take damage as if I was, also seems to happen with other transparent blocks MCPE-17372 breathing bar MCPE-17385 When you touch doors or signs on the wall you will start to drown MCPE-17990 When we drink a potion of fire resistance and were below the lava appears the respiration bubbles as if we are below the water and can die but appears in the chat "you suffocated on a wall" MCPE-18905 When we are being suffocated by some block the breathing bar appears as if we are under water MCPE-28137 Drowning in lava without air meter MCPE-35886 Air Bubbles not in water MCPE-36376 Drowning in lava, it's a bug? MCPE-36913 Lava breath bubbles MCPE-38231 It Appears To Be Underwater When Inside MCPE-40205 Water bubbles in lava MCPE-71555 Lava air bubbles MCPE-74774 Bug de afogamento embaixo da lava MCPE-75877 Armor with Fire Protection drown players MCPE-76550 we can drown in lava MCPE-80760 Players Can Drown In Lava MCPE-99166 Players drown in lava MCPE-102362 for some reason I was digging and lava fell on me but It was acting like I was swimming air bubbles and every thing

Attachments

Comments

migrated
[media][media]
migrated

Confirmed on Samsung Galaxy Tab S. Android 5.0.2

PlantSeed

Well, It makes sense when you suffocate you will lose an air. But it doesn't make any sense when your head are nearby or not inside the block, e.g:

  1. Near by trapdoors,

  2. Under half-slab,

  3. Drowning in lava,

  4. Inside fence gates.

migrated

Confirmed on Samsung Galaxy Tab 3v (SM T116 NU) with Android Kitkat 4.4.4

Johnmacro

Also happens on sign block and it'll look like players die by drowing because of that, but we die by suffocating. Kinda weird.

migrated

Confirmed on my Galaxy Tab S running android 6.0.1

migrated

Fixed in 0.15.90.8

migrated

oops still affects lava

migrated

@unknown do you mean that you lose air when submerged in lava or also when near lava but not in it?

I would expect that even with fire resistance, you still cannot breath when submerged in lava. But perhaps that is not the case in PC?

migrated

@unknown When submerged in lava. But I do not know. Only I mentioned this because it is in the list in the description of the issue.

migrated

The drowning effect now only happens when swimming in lava when completely submerged. To test use fire resistance. When you swim in lava you will see the water bubbles as if you're drowning.

migrated

Also affects fence,fence gate an trapdoor

[Mojang] Mega_Spud (Jay)

@@unknown - Have you updated to 0.15.90.8? They (should) have been fixed.

Ariel Diaz

Affecting 1.0.3.0 (swimming in lava does show the oxygen bar, but is this confirmed as a bug?)

[Mojang] Mega_Spud (Jay)

Lava drowning bug still present in 1.0.4.0

Ariel Diaz

Affects 1.0.4.1.

I should mention that this also affects mobs as well, not just the player.

Ariel Diaz

Affects 1.0.4.11.

HelenAngel

But it doesn't matter if it's water or lava- lava will suffocate you just like water will. There's no air in lava.

[Mojang] Mega_Spud (Jay)

Reopening - as of 1.2.5.52, bubbles no longer appear when submerged in lava (with fire resistance potion) but you will still drown and die after x amount of time.

(The death message is "[Player] suffocated in a wall")

migrated

Also appears when you're sufficating.

migrated

Still affects 1.6.0.1

migrated

Still affects 1.6.0.8

migrated

This also affects whenever you are suffocating in blocks.

migrated

Idk if this is arguable but the barrier block as well

migrated

I think the lava suffocation should be kept because it makes sense. How are you supposed to be able to breath when you're submerged in a pile of molten rock?

silentwisperer

This bug still affects 1.9, and now also applies to slime blocks!

I have also suffered from the lava drowning bug myself in survival, not cool that no matter how much fire rez and fire protection you have, you still need water breathing and respiration in order to not drown. in lava. 😐

silentwisperer

Still affects 1.11.4

migrated

affects 1.13.0.1

migrated

affects 1.13.0.2

migrated

drowning in lava is working as intended

Whomsky

Drowning in lava was not intended. Now fixed in 1.16.0.51 Beta

[Mod] LateLag

It's still not fixed in the latest beta.

silentwisperer

This issue needs to be reopened, it still affects 1.16.20

GoldenHelmet

I cannot reproduce in vanilla in 1.16.20. I do not get an air meter in lava in survival mode. If you do, please check that it isn’t due to an add-on, and provide a video or test world.

thistriagonalsign

I am still unable to reproduce this bug myself, but I attached a clip of silentwisperer demonstrating the bug on a livestream. Truly Bedrock is on 1.16.20.

migrated

I have this bug as well. I drown in lava in the nether. 

migrated

(Unassigned)

34825

Confirmed

Android

Android 4.4.4

bubble, door, drown, java-parity, underwater, vanilla-parity

1.16.0.60 Beta, 1.16.0.59 Beta, 1.16.0.58 Beta, 1.14.25.1 Beta, 1.13.1, ..., 1.4.3.0, 1.5.0.10, 1.4.2.0, 1.9.0, 1.14.60 Hotfix

1.16.0.63 Beta, 1.16.0.51 Beta, 1.2.5.52, 1.16.0

Retrieved