mojira.dev
MC-2604

Walking on non-solid blocks with no collision plays their respective walking sounds

The bug

If you have a stone block with a torch on the top and jump down onto it, the sound related to walking on a wooden floor plays instead of that for walking on stone.

How to reproduce

  1. Place a line of blocks (not wood) on the ground

  2. Place torches on the ground next to it

  3. Sneak on the edge of the line of blocks until your center is above the torch

  4. Walk straight along the line of blocks
    ❌  You'll hear the sound of wood from the torches

[media]

Related issues

MC-3700 Jumping over torches makes wood sound play. MC-7942 Bug Walking MC-8778 When you the player runs and jumps or jump on torches on grass (maybe any block) it makes the sound of the player walking on wood logs. MC-13394 Jumping on a block with torch makes wood sound MC-14904 Jumping on fire produces wood step sound. MC-15163 Sprint Running On Redstone Sound MC-19960 Transparent blocks play sounds of their block type when passing over them. MC-25244 Running and jumping on wool gives the sound of wood MC-25382 A Not Intended Sound Effect For Pressure Plates MC-26923 Walking noise when jumping over a torch. MC-46743 Walking on torches MC-51191 Walking sounds continue when you are in the air above rails. MC-72686 "Walking" on torches MC-94126 Water particles shows up when you run on a block next to water MC-98339 Wrong sounds on blocks with torches MC-108805 Footstep Sound when you Jump over Redstone MC-109031 Sound of Sign MC-110844 Walking sound when flying through walkthrough blocks MC-123608 Snow layers play step sound when player is not on them MC-129159 Jumping into a transparent wood object's space produces a wooden footstep noise MC-133633 Running on Fire Wool Sound MC-133822 when moving forward and jumping over a torch it makes a noise like running on wood MC-136620 Landing sound incorrect when landing on blocks attached with torches/levers/many other things MC-136652 Jumping over torch plays wood walking sound effect MC-138454 Bamboo falling footstep bug MC-150356 Walking sound being played in air above snow MC-152615 Footstep noise walking in torches. MC-156646 Landing sound effect played when jumping over lantern MC-175810 Incorrect sound when falling through air blocks containing torches etc MC-181904 There is a sound bug when (running and jumping) on rails and torches MC-186677 jump spriting on the rail, player can make step sound MC-190165 Torch plays wrong sound MC-193622 when i run and jump over torches the running on wood sound plays MC-200186 I can hear snow footsteps even though im sprinting and jumping MC-206054 Walking on lightning rod sounds play when not walking on them MC-206475 Flying or jumping over torches makes a wooden sound MC-213679 When jump sprinting on snow covered blocks, the snow sound effect for walking still plays while in the air MC-227470 Light Block Audio Glitch? MC-229135 Walk sound is played when you fall and move through light blocks MC-229920 Walking on thin blocks midair creates a sound MC-230238 Light blocks play sound when stepped on MC-230251 Jumping through banners plays block.wood.step sound despite being airborne MC-230904 Sound glitches and particle glitches when sprint jumping on snow layers MC-231648 Light block has footstep sound of stone MC-232421 Walking on stone sound plays when is shouldn't MC-234860 Passing through Light Blocks in the air make walking noise MC-239783 Snow footstep sounds don't stop when jumping MC-240193 Wood surface sound when running and jumping over signs MC-243443 Running on Snow Sound Bug MC-245090 Dead bush sound error? MC-248236 Player interacts wrongly with light blocks MC-255219 Light blocks make noise when jumped through MC-255594 Footsteps on light blocks MC-257216 Sprint-jumping on snow causes problems with snow-stepping sounds MC-257837 Light Creates Walking Sound MC-258732 Walking on light block creates sound MC-260204 Signs MC-261326 Light block walking sound

Attachments

Comments

migrated
[media][media][media]
Paulquappe

it happened to me as well on windows 7, minecraft 1.4.4 (don't know java version). i jumped on a torch on grass and the wood-sound came instead of grass.

Phssthpok Pak

Just noticed whilst checking in 13w09b that the same happens with redstone torches, redstone repeaters and signs.
Also, comparators and hoppers!

Cody Farrell

Can confirm in 13w41a.

nate_dawww

Confirmed in 1.7.2.

lapppy

Confirmed in 1.7.4.

bret a spath

thats on purpose by mojang thats the sound for torchs

Swekob

Confirmed for 15w46a & 1.8.8

Suggested summary change:

Walking on non-solid blocks with no collision plays their respective walking sounds

Swekob

Strongly related to MC-1133

FaRo1

I want to note that this doesn't affect particles. Apparently they get calculated differently.

Nate Kean

Confirmed in 1.12-pre5.

bemoty

Can confirm for MC 1.12.1.

Thierry K

Can confirm for 18w11a.

MacchuPicchu96

This is affecting me, too, on version 1.13 Prerelease 7.

Levi Powell

It does this when running through tall grass as well just not as noticeable because the sound of tall grass on grass is the same

Kroppeb

Can confirm for 1.14.1pre1

muzikbike

Affects 19w38b, can I request ownership?

muzikbike

Affects 19w39a

muzikbike

Affects 19w40a

muzikbike

Affects 19w41a

Jack McKalling

When testing MC-1133, you can notice this bug at the same time. If you walk along the edge of blue/compact ice, with torches on the floor next to it, your walking speed will be normal and you'll hear wood stepping sounds, eventhough you're suspended by ice. This is how I've been testing these two bugs at once.

Basically the game appears to calculate the sound and other effects depending on what is under the center of the player, and not what you're actually walking on. Jumping/falling/walking is all the same therein. I tried to rephrase the summary of this ticket to be more concise about this, but it's difficult and I don't want to make too many assumptions about the mechanic.

Lightning_11

I thought that this was a feature since your character is kicking the torch as they fall...

yenseo Jang

Relates of MC-1133

Avoma

Can confirm in 21w05a.

Avoma

Can confirm in 21w05b.

Avoma

Relates to MC-8820.

violine1101

Also happens with light blocks for example, see MC-227470

Avoma

Can confirm this in 21w39a.

ampolive

Can confirm in 21w40a.

Avoma

Can confirm in 1.18.1.

Avoma

Can confirm in 1.18.2.

MacchuPicchu

Present in 1.19-pre1.

MacchuPicchu

Present in 1.19-pre2.

MacchuPicchu

Present in 1.19-pre3.

MacchuPicchu

Present in 1.19-pre4.

MacchuPicchu

Present in 1.19-pre5.

MacchuPicchu

Present in 1.19-rc1.

MacchuPicchu

Present in 1.19-rc2.

MacchuPicchu

Present in 22w24a.

Avoma

Can confirm in 1.19.1.

Brain81505

Can confirm in 23w06a

MacchuPicchu

Present in 1.19.4.

Avoma

This issue was present in 23w17a but no longer occurs in 23w18a. This issue has been fixed in 23w18a.

Phssthpok Pak

(Unassigned)

Confirmed

Low

Sound

sound, torch, walking

Minecraft 1.4.2, Minecraft 1.4.4, Minecraft 1.4.5, Snapshot 13w01b, Snapshot 13w02a, ..., 1.19.1, 1.19.2, 22w44a, 1.19.3, 1.19.4

23w18a

Retrieved