mojira.dev
MC-48071

Unsupported mobs don't behave as expected

Moderator Note

Giants, Zombie Horses, Killer Bunnies and Illusioners are currently unsupported mobs that are not fully implemented. They were created as a test-base for proof of concept on alternate styles of mobs.

Functionality of those mobs at this time may be limited compared to other mobs due to this.

I know that Giants are unsupported/unused mobs, but in 14w06b, they no longer move, which is annoying. They seem to be blocked. In previous versions, they moved "normally".

Even if they are unused, Giants are not completely abandoned since they can wear an equipment to their size as of 14w06a, for example: http://www.reddit.com/r/Minecraft/comments/1x4dw5/giants_wearing_armor_is_nothing_try_slimes/cf8b45n?context=3

Related issues

MC-9552 Giant spawner don't work. MC-16832 Giants do not get damage when hit by Instant Health MC-18843 Smite enchantment dosen't effect Giants MC-32817 Giants (big zombies) named via nametag display their name poorly MC-36286 Giants Get Stuck In Lava MC-37648 Killing a giant doesn't get tracked in the world's statistics MC-40780 Summoned Giant Dissapearing MC-43335 Giant doesn't have a zombie hit sound MC-44018 Arrows sometimes pass through Giants on water MC-47834 When attacking/killing a Giant, they make player sounds instead of Zombie sounds. MC-47944 mobs MC-48141 Giants no longer attack players MC-49108 Giant dont attack (Gamemode=Survival) MC-49454 Giant doesn't attack MC-49682 Giants don't move or attack MC-50604 Giants lack AI MC-50623 Skulls Don't Render on Giants MC-50901 Giant is not Undead MC-52437 giants not hostile MC-55676 giant wont attak! MC-56244 Giants are unresponsive even in survival mode MC-58523 Giants will not move. MC-58543 Bug with torch. MC-59628 Giant Zombies MC-59732 Giants not hostile MC-62012 Giant killed by cactus makes no sense MC-64200 Bug seeing a giant MC-64262 Giants can not wear blocks or banners MC-64722 Giants MC-66877 Invisible giants MC-67055 Giant MC-69479 giants can't swim MC-69788 Skull doesn't appear on a Giant MC-69980 Giant AI problem MC-71978 Giants always have no AI MC-73411 Killer Rabbit Attack Damage Base is Non-functional MC-75240 No Mob Ai on Giants MC-80287 Giants only render armor as a wearable item. Player skulls are not shown. MC-82099 Giant is invisible in some angles MC-83851 Armor on Giant is rendering darker when Giant is holding an item MC-84571 Giant won't burn in daylight MC-85986 Giants AI Missing MC-87330 Invisible Giant MC-87346 Error Nbt MC-93939 killer bunnys dont attack when hit by other mobs. MC-96049 Giant issue MC-98056 Giant no AI MC-99260 Killer Rabbit Attributes don't work as expected MC-100975 Giant wearing elytra don't show them MC-113085 the killer bunny follow player in creative MC-116600 Giant AI still broken MC-141042 Giants convert to normal-sized drowned MC-141043 Giants move way too fast MC-141059 Giant will turn into a drowned when they are underwater MC-141131 Giants hitbox bug MC-141132 Giants are glitched MC-141134 Giant becomes regular drowned after drowning. MC-141139 Giants phase through blocks MC-143342 Giants have no more zombies AI. MC-153153 The giant dose not have an AI MC-156669 Villagers fear no giant MC-159338 Illusioners shoot at nothing MC-166899 Giants MC-170624 Other than traditional helmets, items are not visible when placed in the head slot of giants MC-176630 Giant Skulls not rendering MC-180404 Giants unable to wear player heads and mob heads MC-181697 Giant looks like it's floating when riding a minecart MC-181708 Killer bunnies not attacking MC-182224 Only a few amount of illusioners hold their bows more diagonally MC-183078 giant despawn when i die MC-186648 Killer Bunny can be summoned in peaceful mode MC-193567 Giants wearing heads do not appear to MC-196977 Nametagging giant fails MC-196978 Giant cannot be injured above the waist MC-196979 Giant doesn't have separate injury sounds MC-201409 Illusioners dont have a celebrating raid sound MC-202281 Giants unable to wear playerheads MC-202965 killer rabbit is not afraid of ravager MC-204306 Illusioner's Arrows Are Fired From The Back of the Head MC-206273 Illusioners attacking pose is stuck and start target random enemies MC-207902 Illusioners are delusional MC-208088 giant can't breath underwater MC-208388 Illusioners still split when stop attacking MC-209859 Illusioner sometimes hold their bow sideways MC-218657 The 'Giant' mob does not function MC-219982 Giants hurt by instant of damage and heal by instant of healing MC-223694 I can summon giants outside world border MC-224148 Iron golems don't attack killer bunnies MC-226181 Giants have no AI MC-238617 illusioner item bug MC-274866 The Illusioner is about to attack a dead mob.

Attachments

Comments

migrated
[media]
migrated

Why is it invalid, beyond the fact that Giants are unsupported?

migrated

Please reopen my report.

migrated

Although the report has been marked as invalid, the issue still affects the latest version.

galaxy_2alex

It's Invalid because Giants are not supported if they have any bugs (confirmed by one of the developers some time ago)

migrated

However Grum has recently made the armor to their size, so i don't understand. But thank you for the clarification.

Ezekiel

No, he fixed armor on all mobs (and then blocked it on the ones that didn't look correct.)

migrated

Giants are finish mobs, just that there unused, there were added in the classic times

migrated

I summon giants with armor ezekial

galaxy_2alex

Giants are unsupported, we have the official confirmation fro the Developers.

migrated

indeed unsupported, they were never finished, and the armor was a bug that it would render on all mobs, but it got fixed for the ones that don't look correct

migrated

giants were not test :/

migrated

humans and rana were test

migrated

how is torches unused!?

[media]
migrated

it got mentioned thetre that it was of the wrong duplicate, however, Giants were a test mob, humans and rana were as well, however Giants are just kept in the game but remaint unused and thus remained in there test fase

marcono1234

Confirmed for:

  • 15w31a Giants only render Armor, but not for example skulls. I don't quite understand why because it should be just the same like it is for Zombies except with a larger scale, or am I wrong here?

migrated

this is invalid, no need to comment

Bentroen

@unknown, you're not totally right. If something is in the game, it should be properly supported and not contain any bugs. Since giants are in the game somehow, test or not, they should have proper support, or otherwise, completely removed. But "half-support" can't exist. It should either be supported or not be in the game. So, since Mojang hasn't stated anything about the model disappearing, this can, in fact, be considered a bug.

[Mod] Neko

FVbico, please look at Bentroen's comment. You're basically saying it's fine to leave bugs in the game and just call it "unsupported".

migrated

look at the moderator note above...

Moderator Note

Giants and Skeleton/Zombie Horses are currently unsupported mobs that are not fully implemented. They were created as a test-base for proof of concept on alternate styles of mobs.

Functionality of Giants at this time may be limited compared to other mobs due to this.

and @unknown said:

It's Invalid because Giants are not supported if they have any bugs (confirmed by one of the developers some time ago)

Giants are unsupported, we have the official confirmation fro the Developers.

migrated

they said that skeletons are unsupported and they recently added them in, maybe zombie horse and giants will be too. I HAVEN'T LOST FAITH YET!

migrated

requesting that the moderator note get's changed, skeleton horses are now supported (not sure about the zombie variant) but gianta and killer bunnies aren't supported

migrated

illusioners should be supported if their planning to add them

anthony cicinelli

Until they are officially added in game they will not be supported @unknown

migrated

This comments section is like the Flat Earth Society.

migrated

(Unassigned)

Unconfirmed

giant, horse, skeleton, zombie

Minecraft 14w06b, Minecraft 14w07a, Minecraft 14w08a, Minecraft 14w10b, Minecraft 14w11b, 20w17a

Retrieved