mojira.dev
MC-188987

When standing on certain non-full blocks, the player gets pushed off if there is a lower area next to the block

Resolved
Fixed
230

The bug

The player is pushed away when he is at the edge of a block of farmland, grass path or soul sand.

How to reproduce

  1. Place blocks of soul sand or grass path or farmland

  2. Put yourself on one of the blocks at the edge and do not move
    → ❌ You can see that you are pushed off the block

Examples

Here are examples in videos:

  • Farmland:

[media]

  • Soul sand:

[media]

Linked issues

clones 1

is duplicated by 374

MC-14329 horses fall through floor while on carpet Resolved MC-14331 Horses drop normal saddles when they die Resolved MC-14342 all snapshot items are not yet put into menu sections Resolved MC-188989 Standing on soul sand pushes players off Resolved MC-188990 Sliding on hoed dirt or shovelled dirt. Resolved
369 more links

relates to 1

Attachments

The player is pushed away when he is at the edge of a block (farmland).mp4
The player is pushed away when he is at the edge of a block (soul sand).mp4

Comments 29

i have experienced this issue, but i am being pushed UP onto nearby stairs (quartz)... this issue does not work when next to oak stairs

 

edit: okay, so ive done some playing around and its pushing me off the path blocks onto the stairs because underneath the stairs is a top half slab. if i remove the top half slab and replace with a full block, i do not get pushed.  interestingly if i use leaf blocks, i still get pushed.

Without a doubt due to fix for MC-166718.

The fix for both of these would be to make every mob suffocate so long as their eye level is inside of a block that can be collided with, rather than just declaring soul sand, farmland and grass paths to be full blocks, with full blocks being the only blocks that can suffocate.

Akash Harapanahalli

I am also having this problem. I just wanted to add that when jumping back onto the soul sand or path block, there is some kind of invisible barrier that I need to jump over.

Jeremy Mulinix

This will also happen in the Nether, standing on the edge of a Lava Lake is quite treacherous. It's like sliding downhill.

Same problem with mine, only seems to be 2 blocks of farmland that are inline with a water-block. https://youtu.be/d1sBrMyJLjU

19 more comments

Same thing here. When i'm in water and go onto farmland i cannot get onto it . Very odd.

it's not like a water flow because this not affect item dropped on the farmland block.

Hi everyone,
just a reminder that every comment here is currently sent to 52 people. Please ONLY leave a comment if you have something important to add that hasn't been mentioned here yet.
If you want to express that you're experiencing this issue too, please use the vote function instead of leaving a comment.
This bug is currently being worked on by @unknown, but keep in mind that it's currently the weekend, so you may need to wait a while for the fix to be available in the next pre-release.

Doesn't just have to be a partial block. Any transparent block placed next to a partial-height block appears to exhibit this behavior.

Does not require trying to jump from one height to another.

Reproed with: eight layers of snow placed next to (on the same level as) farmland. Simply try to walk off of the transparent block onto the farmland (path, block, soul sand).

Does not repro with a snow block placed next to farmland.

Does not repro with seven snow layers rather than farmland next to a transparent block.

Jeffrey Wenger

https://clips.twitch.tv/EnticingPluckyChowderDancingBaby My Girlfriend playing on 1.16 Pre 5 as she jumping up path it was pushing her off

Jack Kersting

mgatland

Confirmed

Very Important

Collision

farmland, grass-path, player, pushed, soul-sand

1.16 Pre-release 5

1.16 Pre-release 6

Retrieved